Is The Modern Church Planting Movement “Elitist”?

by | Jul 31, 2013 | Church Leadership, Church Planting | 1 comment


Last time I wrote about 6 Things Church Planters Can Learn From Ducks.  Today, however, I might just ruffle some feathers.  I recognize that I’m going against the tide.  I feel almost like Micaiah going against Ahab and the 400 prophets in 1Kings 22. So read on with your peril!

I was reading the other day about the Populist Party which was begun in the US around the 1890s.  It was established because they felt that the political parties of the day, called the “elites,” were overlooking the “needs” of the common man.

I can’t help but wondering if we’ve arrived at this same place in US church history.  Has the post modern church planter of today become the “elitist” establishment?  With every pastor dressing alike – every foyer offering coffee, donuts and more- every auditorium outfitted with black ceilings, flashing colored lights, offering a concert-like atmosphere – and I almost forgot, no bibles. Aren’t they all the same?

I realize that this is the accepted wisdom of the day, but isn’t it time for some fresh thinking?  What are we doing, how we’re doing it and what do we hope to accomplish in our church services? Are we truly equipping the people of God to face eternity or rather to just have a “happy life” and live for now? Has our focus been “lost in earthly culture?”  Is this the new syncretism – merging the secular with the spiritual? Thousands may come, but to what end? Has the time of the post modernists passed?

I saw an article about a pastor whose head was half-shaved, covered with tattoos, scruffy- bearded and wearing a cuffed shirt; thousands are coming to his services. Now before you jump all over me, I think that for him, if this is what God has called him to do, so be it; there certainly is Biblical precedence in 2Kings 1:8 “He was a hairy man with a leather girdle bound about his loins.”  But, is this now going to be the new normal? Our adequacy must come from God and not the outward accoutrements that are prevalent today.

A while ago, having a Sunday off, we decided to visit another church in a nearby city.  The service began with 2 songs that really said nothing about God, Jesus, or the Holy Spirit.  Then there was a short clip from the movie, Scrooged followed by a 5 minute message on “How to have friends.”  We were then told to go back to the foyer and get some hot chocolate or whatever, a donut, and bring it back into the auditorium.  Then there were 2 more nebbish songs, another clip from the same movie followed by a wrap up of the message.

We left feeling completely empty. Why would anyone get up, get dressed and go out for something like this?  What needs were met? Who felt challenged to develop any fruit of the Spirit?  What seeds of morality, faith, honor, or other Biblical truths were sown?  Are we “feeding their bodies and starving their souls?” Where was the “refreshing of the heart” spoken about by Paul in the book of Philemon? Our country, our churches and our families (what’s left of them) are divided like Israel of old over the direction of the Church in America.

I’m not advocating a return to the past, I’m just wondering what the future will hold. The delivery system is not in question if the purity of the message is maintained. Are there conversions?  Are people following the Lord in baptism?  Is the congregation maturing in the Lord?

I’ll leave you with four questions to consider:

1. Have the post moderns become the elitists of the day?

2. Are we meeting the needs of our people who are struggling with sin or just giving them a venue to assuage their consciences by attendance at “church?”

3. Are we provoking our God to wrath by our syncretistic approach?

4. Whose mantle are you taking up and why?

 “What the Church needs today is not more machinery or better, not new organizations or more and novel methods, but MEN whom the Holy Spirit can use … The Holy Spirit does not flow through methods but through men. He does not come on machinery but on men. He does not anoint plans but men. Natural ability and educational advantages do not figure as factors in this matter; but capacity for faith, the ability to pray, the power of thorough consecration, the ability of self-littleness, and absolute losing of one’s self in God’s glory and an ever-present and insatiable yearning and seeking after all the fullness of God—men who can set the Church ablaze for God; not in a noisy showy way, but with an intense and quiet heat that melts and moves everything for God. God can work wonders if He can get suitable men”. -E. M. Bounds, January 1971

Church Website Hero

Church Website Hero offers a done-for-you service that takes all the stress, hassle and guesswork out of building and managing your church website.