The Ministry Mullet: How to Balance Leadership and Relationships

by | Oct 7, 2024 | Church Leadership, Church Planting, Featured | 2 comments

When you hear the word mullet, you probably think of that infamous hairstyle: business in the front, party in the back. It’s bold. It’s memorable. It’s a mix of two seemingly different styles in one. But what if I told you the mullet is a pretty perfect metaphor for church planting?

 

Stick with me… I’ll explain.

 

In church planting, you’ve got two crucial things going on: professional leadership (the “business”) and authentic relationships (the “party”). Both are non-negotiable. You need a solid plan, clear vision, and systems in place to keep things running. But it would help if you also had real, messy, heart-level connection with people. Balancing both can feel tricky, but when done right, it leads to something beautiful.

Let’s break down how you can rock the “Ministry Mullet” by embracing both sides: leading with strategy and loving with authenticity.

 

Business in the Front: Lead Like You Mean It

 

You might not have gotten into ministry because you love spreadsheets, but here’s the deal: effective church planting takes strategy. You can’t just wing it and hope for the best. A church without direction is like a car without a steering wheel—it might go somewhere, but it probably won’t end well.

So, how do you lean into the “business” side of ministry without becoming all corporate?

 

1. Cast Vision Like It’s Your Job (Because It Is)

 

Every church plant needs a clear vision. Why are you planting this church? Who are you trying to reach? What makes your church different from every other church in town?

You need to know the answers to these questions like the back of your hand. And once you’ve nailed that down, your job is to repeat it. Again and again. Your team needs to hear it, your church needs to hear it, and new people walking in need to catch it too.

A solid vision will act as your North Star. When everything else feels crazy (and it will), your vision keeps you focused on why you’re doing this in the first place.

 

2. Build Systems That Work for You

 

Listen, organization doesn’t have to feel like a straitjacket. It’s actually what frees you up to focus on people. When you’ve got systems in place, you don’t have to keep reinventing the wheel. Systems help you serve better.

Think through some key areas: How are you going to onboard volunteers? How will you follow up with first-time guests? What’s the plan for budgeting and managing resources? You don’t have to create a corporate manual, but you do need systems that help things run smoothly.

Get your ducks in a row so you can spend more time doing what you really love—ministering to people.

 

3. Steward Resources Like a Pro

 

Let’s be real: Church planting costs money. From renting spaces to buying equipment to setting up kids’ ministry, you need resources. As the leader, part of your job is to manage those resources wisely.

That doesn’t mean you have to get all stingy. It just means making smart decisions. Know your budget. Spend where it matters. Fundraise with purpose. And most importantly, encourage a culture of generosity in your church. When people catch the vision, they’re more likely to give their time and resources to it.

 

Party in the Back: People Over Process

 

Now, let’s switch gears to the relational side. The truth is, people aren’t going to stick around because you’ve got a killer organizational chart. They’re going to stay because they feel seen, known, and loved. This is where the “party” comes in—building authentic community and showing people that the church isn’t just another event to attend, it’s a family to belong to.

 

1. Be Intentional About Community

 

No one wants to feel like just another number in the seats. People crave real relationships. And as a church planter, it’s up to you to create spaces where those relationships can happen.

Start with simple things: invite people over for dinner, hang out at local events, and make time to genuinely listen to people’s stories. Set the tone that your church is more than just a Sunday service—it’s a place where lives intertwine, where people grow together, and where real friendships form.

 

2. Lead with Vulnerability

 

People aren’t looking for perfect pastors; they’re looking for real ones. Share your struggles, be open about your journey, and let people see your heart. When you lead with vulnerability, you give people permission to do the same, and that’s where real connection happens.

It’s not about oversharing for the sake of it but about being authentic. Let people see that you’re human, too, that you’re walking this faith journey alongside them, not just from the pulpit.

 

3. Discipleship Happens in Relationships

 

Ministry isn’t about getting people to check off religious boxes. It’s about discipleship—helping people become more like Jesus. And guess what? Discipleship happens best in relationships, not programs.

You can preach all day long, but real transformation happens when people walk with each other through life’s ups and downs. Make space for those deep, relational connections. Whether it’s through small groups, one-on-one mentoring, or just doing life together, focus on relational discipleship. When people know they’re loved and supported, they’ll grow spiritually.

 

Finding the Balance: Leadership Meets Love

 

So, how do you keep this Ministry Mullet balanced? How do you lead with excellence, and love with authenticity?

 

1. Lead with Heart, Not Just Strategy

 

Yes, you need systems and vision, but don’t forget to lead with love. The best leaders are the ones who care deeply about their people. Make space in your schedule for the messy, relational side of ministry. Slow down to check in on someone who’s struggling. Be present in the lives of your congregation, not just in the pulpit.

 

2. Build a Team That Complements You

 

You’re not Superman, and that’s okay. The beauty of the Church is that it’s made up of many parts. Build a team that covers your blind spots. If you’re a relational guy who struggles with administration, bring in someone who thrives in that area. If you’re more of a visionary leader, find team members who can walk with people in the day-to-day.

A well-rounded team lets you lean into your strengths and still have both sides of ministry covered.

 

3. Celebrate Both Growth and Depth

 

It’s easy to get caught up in the numbers—how many people showed up, how many gave, how fast the church is growing. But don’t forget to measure depth as well as growth. Celebrate the relationships being built, the life change happening, and the discipleship taking place.

Growth is important, but without deep, relational roots, it won’t last. So, make sure you’re investing just as much in people’s hearts as you are in the practical side of church life.

 

Final Thoughts on the Ministry Mullet

 

The Ministry Mullet might sound funny, but it’s a great reminder of the dual roles you carry as a church planter/pastor. You’re not just a visionary leader, and you’re not just a relational pastor—you’re both. And when you learn to balance the business in the front with the party in the back, you’ll find that your church doesn’t just grow—it thrives.

So embrace the tension.

Lead with purpose.

Love with authenticity.

And watch what God does when both sides of ministry come together.

Read more blog posts by Jeff Hoglen

Church Website Hero

Church Website Hero offers a done-for-you service that takes all the stress, hassle and guesswork out of building and managing your church website.